L505 Organization and Representation of
Knowledge and Information
School of Library and Information Science
Indiana University
Spring 1998
Instructor: Uta Priss
Email: upriss@indiana.edu
Office: 022 SLIS
Office phone: 812-855-2793
Office hours: Mo 4.00 - 5.00, We 2.00 - 3.00 and by appointment
Course Syllabus
Here are some web pages related to
L505.
Introduction
The representation and organization of information resources is a
primary focus of the information profession. Organizational structures
such as classification schemes, indexes, bibliographies and catalogs have
been devised to provide access not only to the document, but to its
intellectual content - the knowledge or information recorded in the
document. The recent explosive growth in both the number and the variety
of information resources serves to underscore the continuing need for
application of effective methods of representation and organization.
Practical and effective systems of information representation and
organization must depend upon a comprehensive understanding not only of
the theoretical foundations of bibliographic organization but also of the
basic principles of human cognition. Accordingly, this course will
investigate the basic principles and theoretical foundations of
traditional organizational schemes. This investigation will include
materials from traditional librarianship, information science, cognitive
science, semiotics, and artificial intelligence and expert systems that
have contributed to an understanding of how people obtain, store,
retrieve and use information. It will also examine how research in these
areas can inform current practices of representation and organization in
the design of more effective and more efficient information retrieval
systems.
Course Objectives
-
To introduce the student to a broad range of knowledge
representation models drawn from the fields of information science,
communication, semiotics, philosophy, cognitive psychology, and
artificial intelligence.
-
To develop in the student the ability to understand and
effectively apply principles of representation and organization currently
used to provide access to information resources.
-
To provide practical experience in applying the basic
principles of knowledge organization and representation to the indexing,
abstracting and classification of information in several media.
-
To enable the student to analyze information resources
for hypertext indexing.
-
To provide the student with a practical understanding of
the function of subject analysis in indexing and classification.
-
To provide the student with an understanding of the
development and application of controlled vocabularies and syndetic
structures.
-
To introduce the student to the major classification
systems currently in use and to provide the student with the ability to
effectively employ such classification schemes in the representation of
information.
Class Organization
The structure of each class session will center around lectures by the
instructor, group presentations, and class discussions. Lecture, presentations,
and discussions will cover the topic for the session as
indicated on the syllabus. Students are strongly encouraged to
participate actively in all lectures and discussions since each student's
participation in class activities will constitute 1/3 of his/her final grade.
During the first session students will form teams. Each team will compose an
electronic journal for the class and prepare a presentation
for one class session (see below).
Required Readings
There is no required text for this class. However, the text listed below
will be available in the IMU bookstore, in case you would like to purchase it.
Iyer, Hemalata. (1995). Classificatory structures: Concepts,
relations and representation. Frankfurt am Main: Indeks Verlag.
A copy of this book is on Reserve in the SLIS library, as are copies of
other assigned readings. The Class Schedule (contained in this
handout) lists the other readings. It is required
that every student completes every week's readings before the class meeting.
Grading
The grades are given according to the SLIS grading standards.
Good work that meets the course expectations will be assigned
a grade of B. To get a higher grade than B, the students must
demonstrate above average comprehension of the course materials,
knowledge and/or effort.
The final course grade will be computed for each student on the basis
of grades assigned for the following:
Class contribution and listserv discussion | 1/3
|
Team project: journal and presentation | 1/3
|
Final exam | 1/3
|
Each student is expected to complete all course work by the end of the term.
A grade of incomplete (I) will be assigned only if exceptional
circumstances warrant.
Class contribution and listserv discussions
Class contribution does not mean attendance, but the quality and quantity
of contributions to the work of the class. Comments and questions are
equally valuable if they help to clarify the topics
and to move the discussion forward. The assignments and readings
of each week must be completed before the class meeting so that
substantive and meaningful contributions from the students are possible.
It is required that every student demonstrate respect for the ideas,
opinions, and feelings of all other members of the class.
A majordomo distribution list will be used to communicate about course
matters. The students should send comments and questions concerning the
reading materials to this list. Participation in the listserv discussions
will be counted towards class participation, i.e. students who do not
like to speak up in class can contribute their ideas via the listserv.
It is recommended that all students check their email at least
three times a week for messages to the distribution list.
The distribution list is priss_l505@indiana.edu.
Team project: journal and presentation
In the first session the students will form teams of two members each.
Each team will
compile an electronic journal which they make available on the Internet.
(If a team consists of students who have not taken or waived L401, they
can compose a typewritten journal instead. The form of the journal,
electronic or printed, has to be determined during the first class session.)
Only the content and the completeness of the journal and not the
graphical design of the pages or the html encoding will be graded.
Although the design will not be graded, it is expected that the journals
are spell-checked and written in a style which is appropriate for
publication on the Internet.
The journal must at least contain
-
A title page with names of the team members, name of the class,
a list of contents of the journal, and a one paragraph introduction.
All other pages must be linked to this page.
-
An informative abstract, discussion, or summary of each assigned
reading and three index terms (keywords) for each assigned reading.
Each entry for an assigned reading must include full citation
information and the name of the team member who wrote the abstract.
-
Short essays, lists, etc. according to the assignments of each week.
If an assignment is labeled "individual", each team member has to
write the assignment individually and add it to the journal.
Each assignment must carry a heading which indicates the class session
to which the assignment belongs and the team member who compiled it.
-
A faceted classification scheme for the assigned readings.
(Compare the assignment for session 8.)
-
An index for the assigned readings which consists of the index terms
of the assigned readings.
(Compare the assignment for session 9.)
-
A thesaurus for the topics of the class that contains the index terms
of the assigned readings. (Compare the assignment for session 11.)
Optional journal entries may include: (Each optional entry must contain
a heading and the name(s) of the team member(s) who created it.)
-
Review and assessment of ideas presented in class lectures and discussions.
-
Summaries of other relevant readings.
-
Questions raised by readings, class lectures or discussions.
The students are encouraged to read the journals of other students
and to discuss the topics with them.
Journals will be evaluated by the instructor at three separate
points during the semester (The day following session 5, session 9,
and session 13).
At each review, a letter grade for each individual student
will be assigned based on
-
completeness of the journal,
-
continuous additional effort (for grades better than B),
-
evidence
of active intellectual involvement with the subject content of the course.
The final journal grade will be computed as an average of the three
review grades.
Group presentation
During the first class session each team will get
a topic assigned that is related to one session.
The topics consist of a subject or subject area, such as
a certain classification system or a certain aspect of thesaurus research.
The team will prepare a list of references for the topic, study
the structures of information or knowledge contained in the topic, and
apply the terms and concepts learned from this course to the topic.
The team will give a 20 to 30 minute presentation on the topic which
will highlight the important features of the topic and
present the results of the team's analysis, including a critical
evaluation of the subject.
Handouts of 1 or 2 pages containing the outline of the talk,
the main statements and the references will be prepared.
The groups are recommended to
consult the instructor several times throughout the semester
to clarify questions and to discuss details of the topic.
Final Exam
The final exam will be a take-home exam consisting of 4
essay questions and will be distributed at the conclusion of class session
12. It will be due at the beginning of the class session 14.
A note on plagiarism
The students must clearly indicate if they use materials from
other sources, such as textbooks or Internet webpages. Full citation
information must be given for such sources. The entries of the journal
must contain information on the authors, i.e.
whether they have been written by all members
of the team or by an individual member.
Academic and personal misconduct by students in this class are defined
and dealt with according to the
procedures in the Code of Student Ethics.
Class Schedule
Session: 1. Introduction to Organization of Knowledge and
Information
1.12; Topics:
-
Introduction to the course
-
What is organization?
-
Print-based vs. electronic forms of organization
Assignments (not to be included in the journal):
-
Analyse how your personal library is organized. Which other
methods of organizations are possible.
-
Analyse the methods of organization used in a phone-book. Which possibilities
of information retrieval offers a phone-book on CD-ROM compared to a
printed phone-book? Take notes. You may be able to use them for the
assignment in Session 11.
-
Discuss with your team members the organization of your web pages and
your team work.
How many pages will you have? Which entries will be together on one page?
Will you include pages for the individual team members?
1.19; Martin Luther King Day; No Class
Session: 2. Data, Information, and Knowledge
1.26; Topics:
-
What is information? Knowledge? Representation?
-
Organization of and access to information
-
Interdisciplinarity of information
Assignments (journal):
-
Write a page for your journal which contains
definitions of `information', `data', `knowledge' as they appear
in encyclopedias, dictionaries, text books or on the Internet.
For each definition include the citation information
and an evaluation whether the definition is neutral or belongs
to a certain discipline.
Readings:
- Buckland, Michael. (1991).
-
Information as thing. JASIS, 42, pp 351-360.
- Wilson, P. (1978).
-
Some fundamental concepts of information retrieval. Drexel Library
Quarterly 14 (2), pp 10-24.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata. (1995).
-
Interdisciplinarity. In: Classificatory structures: Concepts,
relations and representation. Frankfurt/Main: Indeks Verlag, pp 12-28.
- (Optional) Machlup, F., and Mansfield, U. (1983).
-
Cultural diversity in studies of information. In:
F. Machlup and U. Mansfield (Eds.), The study of information:
Interdisciplinary messages. New York: John Wiley, pp 3-59.
Session: 3. Abstracting workshop
2.2; Topics:
-
The subject approach
-
Types of abstracts and principles of abstracting
Assignments (journal, individual):
-
Prepare a list of subjects for the three articles.
-
Write an indicative or an informative abstract for the Bush article.
-
Write an indicative or an informative abstract for the other two articles.
Readings:
- Borko, Harold, and Bernier, Charles L. (1975).
-
Characteristics and types of abstracts. In:
Abstracting concepts and methods. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
pp 3-24.
- Lancaster, F. Wilfrid. (1991).
-
Introduction; Indexing principles. In:
Indexing and abstracting in theory and practice. Champaign, Il.: University
of Illinois Press, pp 1-18.
- (Optional) Fidel, Raya. (1986).
-
Writing abstracts for free-text searching. Journal of Documentation,
42 (1), pp 11-21.
Articles for abstracting:
- Bush, Vannevar. (1996/1945).
-
As we may think. Interactions, 3(2), pp 35-46. Originally published in
Atlantic Monthly, 176 (1), pp 101-108. Available
here.
- Gross, Linden. (1996).
-
Steven Spielberg's close encounter with the past. Reader's Digest
(April 1996), pp 71-76.
- Randi, James. (1996).
- Investigating miracles, Italian-style.
Scientific American (February 1996), p 136.
Session: 4. Cognitive Organization of Information
I: Categorization
2.9; Topics:
-
What is categorization or classification?
-
The cultural and cognitive nature of categorization
Assignments (journal, individual):
Visit a grocery store and write an analysis of the store's organization in your
journal. In your analysis, focus on
-
how the merchandise is organized/categorized;
-
why you think this particular organizational structure was adopted; and
-
whether
this organizational/categorization scheme actually helps or hinders the customer
in finding specific items.
Readings:
- Jacob, Elin K. (1991).
-
Classification and categorization: drawing the line. In:
Barbara H. Kwasnik and Raya Fidel (Eds.). Advances in classification
research. Vol. 2, Washington D.C.: American Society for Information Science,
pp 67-83.
- Zerubavel, Eviatar. (1991).
-
Chapters 1, 2, and 4 of The fine line: making distinctions in everyday
life. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp 5-32 and 61-80.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata. (1995).
-
Cognition and Categories. In: Classificatory structures: Concepts,
relations and representation. Frankfurt/Main: Indeks Verlag, pp 40-56.
2.16; No Class
Session: 5. Cognitive Organization of Information
II: Scripts, Schemas, and Mental Models
2.23; Topics:
-
The mental lexicon and information organization/access
-
Cognition and information retrieval and use
-
Scripts, schemas, conceptual graphs, and formal concepts
Assignments (journal, individual):
-
List elements of the script "Shopping in a grocery store".
-
Choose two different persons who shop in the same grocery store,
but have different expectations (eg. an American that moved recently to a new
town, a person from a foreign culture). In what way is their shopping
supported - or not - by the grocery store you analyzed last week?
Try to explain the problems in terms of scripts.
Readings:
- Lakoff, George, and Johnson, Mark. (1980).
-
Metaphorical systematicity: highlighting and hiding. In: Metaphors
we live by. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp 10-13.
- Rumelhart, David E. (1984).
-
Schemata and the cognitive system. In: Wyer and Srull (Eds.).
Handbook of social cognition. Vol. 1, Hillsdale NJ: Lawrence
Erlbaum, pp 161-188.
- Schank, Roger, and Kass, Alex. (1988).
-
Knowledge representation in people and machines. In: Umberto Eco,
Marco Santambrogio and Patrizia Violi (Eds.), Meaning and mental
representation. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, pp 181-200.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata. (1995).
-
Artificial Intelligence and Classification. In: Classificatory
structures: Concepts, relations and representation.
Frankfurt/Main: Indeks Verlag, only pp 164-169.
- (Optional) Wright, Robert. (1996).
-
Can machines think? Time (March 25 1996), 50-58.
- (Optional) Miller, George A. (1956).
-
The magical number seven plus or minus two: Some limits on our capacity
for processing information. Psychological Review 63, 81-87.
Session: 6. Systematic Organization of Information: Classification
3.2; Topics:
-
History of classification systems
-
Types and applications of classification systems
Assignments (not to be included in the journal):
-
Familiarize yourself with the category structure in Yahoo.
Do a search for "classification" in Yahoo.
Where does the term "classification" occur?
Would you have found it by browsing through the hierarchy instead of
searching?
-
Find some sites that use traditional
library classification systems on the Web.
Readings:
- Bliss, Henry Evelyn. (1934).
-
The problem of classification for libraries. In:
The Organization of knowledge in libraries and the subject approach to
books. New York: H. W. Wilson, pp 1-20.
- Bliss, Henry Evelyn. (1934).
-
The principles of classification for libraries. In:
The Organization of knowledge in libraries and the subject approach to
books. New York: H. W. Wilson, pp 21-46.
- Shera, Jesse H. (1965/1950).
-
Classification as the basis of bibliographic organization. In: J. H.
Shera. Libraries and the organization of knowledge. Hamden, CT: Archon
Books, pp 77-96.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata. (1995).
-
Normative principles. In: Classificatory structures: Concepts,
relations and representation. Frankfurt/Main: Indeks Verlag, pp 30-39.
- (Optional) Shera, Jesse H. (1965/1957).
-
Pattern, structure, and conceptualization in classification for information
retrieval. In: J. H. Shera. Libraries and the organization of knowledge
Hamden, CT: Archon Books, pp 112-128.
Session: 7. Classification Schemes I: Enumerative systems
3.9; Topics:
-
Dewey Decimal and Library of Congress Classification
-
Strengths and weakness of enumerative systems
Assignments (not to be included in the journal):
-
Choose one of the books of one of the assigned readings
for this class and find out how it is (or would be)
classified using the Dewey Decimal and the Library of Congress
Classification.
-
Have a look at electronic versions of the Dewey Decimal and Library
of Congress Classification on the Web. Evaluate their usefulness.
Readings:
- Shera, Jesse H. (1965/1961).
-
The dignity and advancement of Bacon. In: J. H. Shera. Libraries
and the organization of knowledge. Hamden, CT: Archon Books, pp 143-150.
- Buchanan, Brian. (1979).
-
Introduction; Classification: definition and uses; The relationships
between classes; Enumerative and faceted schemes; Decisions. In: Theory
of library classification. London: Clive Bingley, only pp 17-44.
- Pietris, Mary Kay (1990).
-
Library of Congress classification. In Bengtson and Hill (eds.).
Classification of library materials. New York, Neal-Schuman.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata. (1995).
-
Structural models of classification. In: Classificatory
structures: Concepts, relations and representation. Frankfurt/Main: Indeks
Verlag, pp 88-96.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata. (1995).
-
Non-faceted classification. In: Classificatory structures:
Concepts, relations and representation. Frankfurt/Main: Indeks Verlag, pp
97-104.
- (Optional) Dewey, Melvil. (1972/1927).
-
Decimal classification and relative index. In: A. F. Painter (ed.).
Reader in classification and descriptive cataloging. NCR Microcard
Editions, pp 81-86.
3.16; Spring Recess; No Class
Session: 8. Classification Schemes II: Faceted systems
3.23; Topics:
-
Universal Decimal, Bliss and Colon Classification
-
Strengths and weakness of faceted classification systems
-
Comparison of enumerative and faceted classification systems
Assignments:
-
(Journal) Create a faceted classification system for the readings of this class.
Provide a notation for each
reading of the previous sessions.
-
(Not to be included in the journal)
Create a chart table comparing the characteristics of enumerative and
faceted classification systems.
Readings:
- Vickery, Brian C. (1972/1966).
-
Faceted classification schemes. In: A.F. Painter (Ed.).
Reader in classification and descriptive cataloguing. NCR Microcard
Editions pp 107-114.
- Williamson, N. and McIlwaine, I.C. (1994).
-
A feasibility study on the restructuring of the Universal Decimal
Classification into a fully faceted classification system. In: H. Albrectsen
and S. Oernager (Eds.). Advances in Knowledge Organization, Vol
4, Frankfurt/Main: Indeks Verlag, pp 406-413.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata (1995).
-
Faceted Structures. In: Classificatory structures: Concepts,
relations, and representation. Frankfurt/Main: Indeks Verlag, pp 105-125.
- (Optional) Ranganathan, S. R. (1962).
-
Canons of Classification. In: Elements of library classification.
Bombay: Asia Publishing House, pp 45-70.
Session: 9. Indexing: Principles, Practice, and Languages
3.30; Topics:
-
Derived-term systems vs. free indexing languages
-
Natural language vs. controlled vocabulary
Assignments:
-
(Not to be included in the journal)
Familiarize yourself with the LC Subject Headings and the ERIC Thesaurus.
Choose one category term from the LC Subject Headings that also exists in the
ERIC Thesaurus. How is the term represented? Compare the strength and weakness
of LCSH and ERIC (chart table).
-
(Journal) Create an index for the readings in your journal.
Readings:
- Taylor, Arlene G. (1995).
-
On the subject of subjects. Journal of Academic Librarianship 21(6),
484-491.
- Lancaster, F. Wilfrid (1991).
-
Indexing Practice. In: Indexing and abstracting in
theory and practice. Champaign, Il., University of Illinois Press, pp 19-40.
- Lancaster, F. Wilfrid. (1991).
-
Natural language in information retrieval. In: Indexing and
abstracting in theory and practice. Champaign, IL, University of Illinois
Press, pp 193-218.
- Chan, Lois Mai. (1990).
-
Subject analysis tools online: The challenge ahead. Information
Technology and Libraries 9(3), 258-262.
- Humphrey, Susanne M. (1992).
-
Use and management of classification systems for knowledge-based
indexing. In: J. Williamson and M. Hudon (Eds.). Classification
research for knowledge representation and organization. Amsterdam: Elsevier,
pp 89-100.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata. (1995).
-
Vocabularies. In: Classificatory structures: Concepts, relations
and representation. Frankfurt/Main: Indeks Verlag, pp 60-85.
- (Optional) Green, Rebecca. (1992).
-
Insights into classification from the cognitive sciences: Ramifications
for index languages. In: N. J. Williamson and M. Hudson (Eds.).
Classification research for knowledge representation and organization.
Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp 215-222.
Session: 10. Thesauri: Structures and Automatic Construction
4.6; Topics:
-
Semantic relations and syndetic structure
-
Manual vs. automated systems of thesaurus and index construction
-
Knowledge bases
Assignments (not to be included in the journal):
-
Design a thesaurus entry for `thesauri' using the syndetic
structure `UF/BT/RT/NT'. Try to locate `thesauri' in LCSH and
ERIC. Follow the `BT/RT/NT' relations starting at `thesauri'
as far as possible.
Draw graphs of the syndetic structure of the entries `thesauri' in LCSH
and ERIC. Compare the syndetic structures in LCSH and ERIC to your thesaurus
entry.
Readings:
- Aitchison, J., and Gilchrist, A. (1987).
-
Planning and design of thesauri. In: Thesaurus construction: A
practical manual. 2nd ed., London: Aslib, pp 3-10.
- Aitchison, J., and Gilchrist, A. (1987).
-
Structure: basic relationships and classification. In: Thesaurus
construction: A practical manual. 2nd ed., London: Aslib, pp 34-60.
- Soergel, Dagobert. (1985).
-
Terminological control. In: Organizing information. San Diego,
CA: Academic Press, pp 213-222.
- Lancaster, F. Wilfred (1991)
-
Automatic indexing, automatic abstracting and related procedures.
In: Indexing and Abstracting in Theory and Practice.
Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press, pp 219-246.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata. (1995).
-
Artificial intelligence and classification. In: Classificatory
structures: Concepts, relations and representation
Frankfurt/Main: Indeks Verlag, only pp 169-175.
- (Optional) Svenonius, E., et al. (1992).
-
Automation of chain indexing. In: N. J. Williamson
and M. Hudson (Eds.). Classification research for knowledge
representation and organization. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp 351-364.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata. (1995).
-
Faceted approach to indexing systems. In: Classificatory
structures: Concepts, relations and representation. Frankfurt/Main:
Indeks Verlag, pp 127-142.
Session: 11. Thesauri II: Natural Language Thesauri and Graphical Displays
4.13; Topics:
-
Applications of thesauri in Information Retrieval
-
Natural language thesauri (WordNet and Roget's Thesaurus)
-
Graphical displays of thesauri
Assignments:
-
(Journal) Create a thesaurus for the readings in your journal.
-
(Not to be included in the journal)
Locate the word `thesaurus' in WordNet and Roget's International Thesaurus.
How is `thesaurus' classified in both thesauri? How do natural language
thesauri differ from library thesauri, such as LCSH and ERIC?
Readings:
- Lin, Xia (1997)
-
Map Displays for Information Retrieval. Journ. of the Amer.
Soc. for Inf. Sci. 48 (1), pp. 40-54.
- Calzolari, Nicoletta (1988)
-
The Dictionary and the Thesaurus can be Combined. In: Evens,
M. W. (ed.). Relational Models of the Lexicon. Cambridge University Press,
pp 75-95.
- Johnson, Eric H. (1995)
-
A Hypertext interface for a Searcher's Thesaurus.
http://csdl.tamu.edu/DL95/
- Yarowski, David (1992)
-
Word-Sense Disambiguation Using Statistical Models of
Roget's Categories Trained on Large Corpora. Proc. of COLING-92, Nantes,
Aug. 23-28, 1992.
- (Optional) Wilks, Yorick et al. (1996)
-
The Construction of Modern Lexicons. In: Electric Words.
MIT Press, pp 121-136.
Session: 12. Organization and Representation of
Multimedia Materials I: Hypertext
4.20; Topics:
-
Features of hypermedia
-
Representation and navigation
Assignments:
-
(Journal) Analyse the hyperlinks that you have in your journal.
Are they appropriate? Describe the link structure of a perfect
on-line journal that has a thesaurus, an index and a classification system.
-
(Not to be included in the journal)
Have a look at the following web pages and their subpages:
The Xanadu Project and
Ted Nelson's page.
The Bush Symposium "As we may think" page.
Readings:
- Balasubramanian, V. (1994).
-
Hypertext - An introduction. In:
State of the art review on hypermedia issues and applications, pp 2-12.
Converted to HTML by Denys Duchier, March 1994. Available
here.
- Liebscher, Peter. (1994).
-
Hypertext and indexing. In: R. Fidel et al. (Eds.). Challenges
in indexing electronic text and images. Medford, NJ: Learned Information for
American Society for Information Science, pp 103-109.
- (Optional) Nelson, Theodor H. (1994).
-
Xanadu: document interconnection enabling re-use with automatic author
credit and royalty accounting. Information Services & Use, 14, pp 255-265.
- (Optional) Simpson, R., et al. (1996).
-
50 years after "As we may think": The Brown/MIT Vannevar Bush Symposium.
Interactions, 3(2), pp 47-67.
- (Optional) Baumbach, D. (1992).
-
Hypertext. In: Macmillan encyclopedia of computers. New York:
Macmillan, pp 508-511.
Session: 13. Organization and Representation of
Multimedia Materials II: Verbal vs. Nonverbal Subject Analysis
4.27; Topics:
-
Verbal vs. nonverbal subject analysis
-
Automated indexing of nonverbal materials
Assignments (not to be included in the journal):
-
Discuss the pros and cons
of indexing the intellectual content of images based on meaningfulness or
usefulness to patrons, as proposed by Krause.
-
Compare two Internet image index systems:
http://www.sils.umich.edu/Art_History/demoarea/htdocs/index.html
http://wwwqbic.almaden.ibm.com/~qbic/qbic.html
Readings:
- Austin, David L. (1994).
-
An image is not an object: but it can help. In: A. H. Helal and J. W.
Weiss (Eds.). Resource sharing: new technologies as a must for universal
availability of information. Essen: Universitaetsbibliothek Essen, pp 277-294.
- Krause, Michael G. (1988).
-
Intellectual problems of indexing picture collections.
Audiovisual Librarian, 14, pp 73-81.
- Shatford Layne, Sara. (1994).
-
Some issues in the indexing of images. JASIS, 45(8), pp 583-588.
- (Optional) Feder, Judy. (1995?).
-
New directions for image recognition: toward image content-based
retrieval for the World Wide Web. Advanced Imaging, X, 26, 28.
- (Optional) Grund, A. (1993).
-
ICONCLASS: On subject analysis of iconographic representations of works
of art. Knowledge organization, 20, pp 20-29.
- (Optional) Lunin, Lois F. (1994).
-
Analyzing art objects for an image database. In: R. Fidel
et al. (Eds.). Challenges in indexing electronic text and images.
Medford, NJ: Learned Information for American Society for Information Science,
pp 57-72.
Session: 14. Miscellaneous Topics
5.4; Topics:
Readings:
- Fallows, James. (1996).
-
Navigating the galaxies. Atlantic Monthly (April 1996), pp 104-107.
- Pool, Robert. (1994).
-
Turning an info-glut into a library. Science 266, pp 20-22.
- Steinberg, Steve G. (1996).
-
Seek and ye shall find (maybe). Wired (May 1996), pp 108-114.
- (Optional) Svenonius, Elaine. (1992).
-
Classification: Prospects, problems and possibilities. In: N. J.
Williamson and M. Hudon (eds.). Classification Research for Knowledge
Representation and Organization, pp 5-25.
- (Optional) Iyer, Hemalata. (1995).
-
Universals. In: Classificatory structures: Concepts, relations and
representation. Frankfurt/Main: Indeks Verlag, pp 177-191.
- (Optional) Davis, Watson. (1967/1965).
-
The universal brain: Is centralized storage and retrieval of all
knowledge possible, feasible, or desirable? In: M. Kochen (Ed.).
The growth of knowledge. New York: John Wiley, pp 60-65.
Topics for group presentations
Session: 4. Cognitive Organization of Information
I: Categorization
The cultural nature of categorization. For example: color terms in
different cultures.
Session: 5. Scripts, Schemas, and Mental Models
John Sowa's Conceptual Graphs.
Session: 6. Systematic Organization of Information: Classification
Classification systems on the WWW.
Session: 7. Classification Schemes I: Enumerative systems
The structure of the Dewey Decimal Classification.
Session: 8. Classification Schemes II: Faceted systems
Faceted structures in the Universal Decimal Classification.
Session: 9. Indexing: Principles, Practice, and Languages
ISO-Standards for indices and information retrieval.
Session: 10. Thesauri I: Structures and Automatic Construction
Analysis of an automatic indexing system (eg. SMART)
Session: 11. Thesauri II: Natural Language Thesauri and Graphical
Displays
CYC (Doug Lenat's)
Session: 12. Multimedia Materials I: Hypertext
Hypertext
Session: 13. Multimedia Materials II:
Verbal vs. Nonverbal Subject Analysis
Classification and retrieval of images on the Web.
Session: 14. Miscellaneous Topics
(There will be several presentations during this session.)
a) ERIC Thesaurus;
b) WordNet;
c) Classification and Artificial Intelligence;
d) Graphical Interfaces for Thesauri, Indices, or Classification Systems;
e) Automated Categorization of Web Resources;
Students may suggest other topics for this session.
Uta Priss
Mon Jan 19 12:08:46 EST 1998